eval-performance skill

Diagnosing MSBuild Evaluation Performance

Evaluation is the work MSBuild does before any target runs — reading project files, processing imports, expanding globs. This skill helps you find and confirm evaluation bottlenecks. Measure first; recommend a change only when a measurement proves it is warranted.

Confirm the problem before changing anything

Engage only when evaluation is measurably the bottleneck. Do NOT act when:

• The slowness is during compilation or target execution, not evaluation. That is not an evaluation problem — use build-perf-diagnostics instead.
• The complaint is "rebuilds too much" / incremental build. Use incremental-build instead.
• You have no measurement. If no binlog or timing summary shows evaluation is slow, gather one first (see below). Do not guess from reading project files.
• A pattern below appears but evaluation is already fast. Broad globs, deep imports, or EnableDefaultItems are only worth flagging when the numbers show they cost real time. A project that evaluates quickly needs no change.

When a pattern is present but unmeasured, report it as an observation and let the user decide — do not rewrite working configuration to match a "best practice" without evidence it costs measurable evaluation time. Prefer the smallest, most targeted change; never disable SDK defaults as a first move.

MSBuild Evaluation Phases

For a comprehensive overview of MSBuild's evaluation and execution model, see Build process overview.

1. Initial properties: environment variables, global properties, reserved properties
2. Imports and property evaluation: process <Import>, evaluate <PropertyGroup> top-to-bottom
3. Item definition evaluation: <ItemDefinitionGroup> metadata defaults
4. Item evaluation: <ItemGroup> with Include, Remove, Update, glob expansion
5. UsingTask evaluation: register custom tasks

Key insight: evaluation happens BEFORE any targets run. Slow evaluation = slow build start even when nothing needs compiling.

Diagnosing Evaluation Performance

Primary: binlog MCP (preferred)

Use the binlog MCP server (Microsoft.AITools.BinlogMcp, exposed under the binlog MCP namespace) to analyze evaluation performance:

1. Use the evaluations tool to list all evaluations and their durations
2. Use evaluation_global_properties to check for multiple evaluations with differing global properties
3. Use evaluation_properties to inspect evaluated properties for a specific project+TFM
4. Use imports tool to analyze the import chain depth and structure
5. Use properties tool to check for expensive property function evaluations

Fallback: text-log replay and preprocessing (when MCP is unavailable)

Using binlog

1. Replay the binlog: dotnet msbuild build.binlog -noconlog -fl "-flp:v=diag;logfile=full.log"
2. Search for evaluation events: grep -i 'Evaluation started\|Evaluation finished' full.log
3. Multiple evaluations for the same project = overbuilding
4. Look for "Project evaluation started/finished" messages and their timestamps

Using /pp (preprocess)

• dotnet msbuild -pp:full.xml MyProject.csproj
• Shows the fully expanded project with ALL imports inlined
• Use to understand: what's imported, import depth, total content volume
• Large preprocessed output (>10K lines) = heavy evaluation

Using /clp:PerformanceSummary

• Add to build command for timing breakdown
• Shows evaluation time separately from target/task execution

Expensive Glob Patterns

Only pursue these remedies once a measurement shows item evaluation is slow and the globs are the cause; a custom glob that isn't walking large trees is fine.

• Globs like **/*.cs walk the entire directory tree
• Default SDK globs are optimized, but custom globs may not be
• Problem: globbing over node_modules/, .git/, bin/, obj/ — millions of files
• Remedy: use <DefaultItemExcludes> to exclude large directories
• Remedy: be specific with glob paths: src/**/*.cs instead of **/*.cs
• Remedy: use <EnableDefaultItems>false</EnableDefaultItems> only as a last resort (loses SDK defaults) — prefer the two options above first
• Check: grep for Compile items in the diagnostic log → if Compile items include unexpected files, globs are too broad

Import Chain Analysis

• Deep import chains (>20 levels) slow evaluation
• Each import: file I/O + parse + evaluate
• Common causes: NuGet packages adding .props/.targets, framework SDK imports, Directory.Build chains
• Diagnosis: /pp output → search for <!-- Importing comments to see import tree
• Remedy (only if the chain is measurably costly): reduce transitive package imports where possible, consolidate imports

Multiple Evaluations

• A project evaluated multiple times = wasted work
• Common causes: referenced from multiple other projects with different global properties
• Each unique set of global properties = separate evaluation
• Diagnosis: grep 'Evaluation started.*ProjectName' full.log → if count > 1, check for differing global properties
• Fix: normalize global properties, use graph build (/graph)

TreatAsLocalProperty

• Prevents property values from flowing to child projects via MSBuild task
• Overuse: declaring many TreatAsLocalProperty entries adds evaluation overhead
• Correct use: only when you genuinely need to override an inherited property

Property Function Cost

• Property functions execute during evaluation
• Most are cheap (string operations)
• Expensive: $([System.IO.File]::ReadAllText(...)) during evaluation — reads file on every evaluation
• Expensive: network calls, heavy computation
• Rule: property functions should be fast and side-effect-free

Optimization Checklist

• Check preprocessed output size: dotnet msbuild -pp:full.xml
• Verify evaluation count: should be 1 per project per TFM
• Exclude large directories from globs
• Avoid file I/O in property functions during evaluation
• Minimize import depth
• Use graph build to reduce redundant evaluations
• Check for unnecessary UsingTask declarations